Skip to Main Content

A Radical – and Respectful – Historic Home Renovation


Architect Drew Mandel’s radical renovation of a 1920s Georgian Revival brings contemporary artisanal touches

In 2016, architect Drew Mandel, principal of his eponymous firm, was hired to take on a historic home renovation for a family of five. The original house, built in 1924, is both classical and folksy. It has the hallmarks of Georgian Revival architecture – Palladian windows, Tuscan columns – but with irregular elements that complement the surrounding Bracondale Hill neighbourhood, an old garden suburb with arts-and-crafts architecture. In contrast to most Georgian designs, the proportions of the house aren’t quite symmetrical, and embedded in the roof is an eyebrow window that appears to wink as you walk by. Mandel opted to lean into the artisanal aesthetic. “This wasn’t going to be a slick modern renovation,” he says. “There was going to be plenty of texture and softness.”

Historic home renovation - Bassani Fine Cabinetry

White oak millwork by Bassani Fine Cabinetry features prominently in both the kitchen and the family room. Quartzite kitchen countertops and backsplash from Ciot and Marble Trend.

For the exterior, he repointed the bricks and replaced the windows and columns. He also built two additions – a glass box on the west-facing back end of the home and a larger structure on the north side, which connects to the original building via a glass and metal atrium – adding 99 square metres to the 109-square-metre footprint. The side unit, clad in black clay shingles, is shadowy and subdued. “It doesn’t draw attention to itself,” says Mandel. “In heritage design, the new work should always be deferential to the historical elements.”

Bassani Fine Cabinetry

Artisanal touches continue in the master bedroom. Here, there is a hand-trowelled plaster finish on the walls and a custom fireplace with a curved concrete hearth.

The interiors have a kind of classical graciousness about them. The front entranceway steps down to an expansive kitchen–living area. From there, you can head left past a millwork partition and into the dining room, or right through an arched entrance to the den. The second and third floors feature kids’ bedrooms, a yoga studio and a double-height master suite beneath a pitched roof.

Architect Drew Mandel | Historic home renovation - Bassani Fine Cabinetry

In the master ensuite, it’s Azul Valverde limestone for the floors and terrazzo for the vanity and wall panelling. The free-standing BainUltra tub is from Ginger’s.

While the overall palette is simple – oak and white paint – there is plenty of texture: plaster walls in the downstairs living spaces, speckled terrazzo in the master ensuite and occasional touches of vibrant marble, which Mandel purchased at a backyard sale for offcuts. There’s also no shortage of elegant detailing, from the curved base of the kitchen island to the thin reveals above the living room archway and even the ribbed concrete, redolent of ruffled curtains, above the downstairs fireplace. Every room begs to be explored; every surface, to be touched.

Architect Drew Mandel | Historic home renovation - R&A Stairs

The four-storey sculptural staircase was constructed on site (by R&A Stairs) with white oak risers and bent-plywood guards.

The most unique feature in the heritage home is the central stairwell with plaster-finished wooden guards that twist and turn. “It’s evocative of fabric, fluidity and movement,” says Mandel. “It’s the furthest thing from predictable.” The same could be said of the entire project. DREWMANDELARCHITECTS.COM

Architect Drew Mandel | Joel Loblaw Inc. landscaping

On the west-facing back end of the heritage home, Mandel added two dormers clad in powder-coated aluminum and a ground-floor glass extrusion. Limestone- finished concrete steps lead to the pool. Landscaping by Joel Loblaw Inc.



Your Weekly Dose of Modern Design

Sign up for the Designlines weekly newsletter to keep up with the latest design news, trends and inspiring projects from across Toronto. Join our community and never miss a beat!

Please fill out your email address.

The Magazine

Get the Latest Issue

From a sprawling family home in Oakville to a coastal-inspired retreat north of the city, we present spaces created by architects and interior designers that redefine the contemporary.

Designlines 2024 Issue